投的一个很水的：energies，然后一个月后返回大修，请问问题怎么解决。

　　投的一个很水的：energies，然后一个月后返回大修，请问问题怎么解决。。投的一个很水的：energies，然后一个月后返回大修，下面是回复意见。两个reviewer，我觉得技术上的问答都很好回答，我要么修改文章，要么解释，但是第二个reviewer的第一个问题和第四个怎么回答啊；说我的论文很简单，而且很多已经被其他发表了（大实话,呵呵），还有就是我没有考虑其他的情况。但是我肯定要反驳他呀，不然论文不就玩了，想问问有没有大家有没有类似的模板之类的，能够令回复很可气，但是又要反驳他。
Review Report 1
English Language and Style
( ) English language and style are fine
( ) Minor spell check required
(x) Extensive editing of English language and style required
( ) I dont feel qualified to judge about the English Language and Style
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
The paper deals with the timing subject of piezoelectric vibration energy harvesting.
The Authors discuss the influence of constraints and mass on cantilever and simply supported beams and compare their finite element simulation results with experimental data.
The paper must be modified before being suitable for publication on Energies, the following points should be carefully considered.

1,Information on maximum and average electric power and/or energies generated by piezoelectric materials in the considered configurations should be obtained both in the simulations and in the experiments.
2,In many figures the Authors show the "quality of the mass" on x axis, probably meaning the value of mass added to vibrating beams, this should be changed in all figures.
3,The references should be updated with the most recent papers on Energy harvesting and vibrating beams, as e.g. the following one:

Experimental verification of a bridge-shaped, nonlinear vibration energy harvester. Gafforelli, G., Corigliano, A., Xu, R., Kim, S.-G., Applied Physics Letters, 105 (20), 203901, 2014.




Review Report 2

English Language and Style
( ) English language and style are fine
( ) Minor spell check required
(x) Extensive editing of English language and style required
( ) I dont feel qualified to judge about the English Language and Style
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
In this paper, the authors investigated the effects of different fixation modes of beams (simply supported and cantilever) on the natural frequency and voltage of the harvester when changing the masses and length-width ratio.
1, As a first look, the results look so and most of them were published in the literature.
2, Furthermore, the authors did not mention how they get the values of the generated voltage.
3, What type of excitation is considered (direct, parametric, random)?? Nothing is clear in this paper.
4, In addition to that, it looks like the authors do not follow or read the recent papers in energy harvesting when considering other scenarios, such as shape of effects [1,2], length-width effects [3], complex-shape effects [4,5], boundary condition effects [6-8], electrical effects [9,10], bending-torsion effects [11]...
1- Ben Ayed et al. "Design and performance of variable-shaped piezoelectric energy harvesters, Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 2014"
2- Rosa and De Marqui "Modeling and analysis of a piezoelectric energy harvester with varying cross-sectional area, Journal of Shock and Vibration, 2014"
3- Abdelkefi et al. "Modeling, validation, and performance of low-frequency piezoelectric energy harvesters, Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 2014"
4- Sharpes et al. "Comparative Analysis of One-Dimensional and Two-Dimensional Cantilever Piezoelectric Energy Harvesters, Energy Harvesting and Systems, 2014"
5- Sharpes et al. "Two-dimensional concentrated-stress low-frequency piezoelectric vibration energy harvesters, Applied Physics Letters, 2015"
6- Tang and Yang "A nonlinear piezoelectric energy harvester with magnetic oscillator, Applied Physics Letters, 2012"
7- Abdelkefi and Barsallo "Comparative modeling of low-frequency piezomagnetoelastic energy harvesters, Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 2014"
8- Abdelkefi and Barsallo "Nonlinear analysis and power improvement of broadband low-frequency piezomagnetoelastic energy harvesters, Nonlinear Dynamics, 2015"
9- Renno et al. "On the optimal energy harvesting from a vibration source, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2009"
10- Abdelmoula et al. "Ultra-wide bandwidth improvement of piezoelectric energy harvesters through electrical inductance coupling, European Physical Journal-Special Topics, 2015"
11- Abdelkefi et al. "An energy harvester using piezoelectric cantilever beams undergoing coupled bending–torsion vibrations, Smart Materials and Structures, 2011"

5, In addition to these improvements, the authors should check all used English. They should also stress on the novelty of their paper. If they consider my comments and show the reader the significance of this work, positive feedback will be given.
===有问必答===

其实我也不太清楚， 但是从IF，还有审稿日期，还有是开源的。个人感觉比较水。
----

也想试试。就是觉得太贵了点。不过看你的这个意见，应该是没大问题了
----
我试过，都没送审就拒了…说不符合期刊


----

谢谢了，很好，我基本上按照你说的方向改的，送你个小红花


----
引用这些文献，好好总结，找到不同点，说明你的文章有啥新结果


----
LZ，请问你的这篇文章后来中了吗？我的在pending阶段了
----
楼主你好，我也关注了这个期刊，请问感觉真的很水吗？我也想试试啊。
----
个人感觉还不错，我们实验室整车能量控制的，的人还比较多。
----

他们好像就是只要你投的paper没有这个研究领域的审稿人，就会直接拒搞。
----
楼主，这个是sci吗？哪个国家的啊？ 很水吗？收不收数学相关算法的文章啊？
----
这个刊和energy什么关系啊，貌似energy比较牛啊