大家看看这个退稿信是什么意思。。。
大家看看这个退稿信是什么意思。。。。第一天投了Journal Of Electronic imaging, 第二天就被退稿了,以下是退稿信:
I have reviewed the subject of your recently submitted paper and have decided that although your work may be correct, the specific subject is not appropriate for Journal of Electronic Imaging. Specifically, the focus of the manuscript is on the numerical algorithm used for the so-called "Ambrosio-Tortorelli Model". This work would be better assessed and appreciated in a journal on numerical methods rather than in JEI. I am therefore declining the manuscript. I suggest you examine other publications, such as those in your list of references, that would be more appropriate to the subject and to the audience for your paper.
I regret having to decline your manuscript. I appreciate the time and effort required to carry out this type of study.
大家帮忙分析一下这是什么原因,是真的内容不适合还是编辑觉得文章水平不行婉拒了(文章是一个模型的新算法,图像分割领域)。本人菜鸟,第一次,不知道水的深浅,请大家给点啊。。。
===有问必答===
都是废话不用当真,就是看不上你的文章。用数学方决专业问题,专业期刊叫你转投数学期刊,数学期刊也可以叫你转投专业期刊。多数解决专业问题的文章都少不了数学内容,甚至数学方法为主,难道都去投数学期刊?
----
不符合期刊要求吧, 对于你的想法就是说是不是水平不行, 你可以找两篇该期刊的和你工作相似的文章比较一下, 比较一下创新性, 实验, 写作等细节,就可以得到答案。 还有一种可能性就是你比较倒霉 分配的这个编辑不欣赏你的文章。 希望能帮到你。
----
楼主,你的jei大概写了多少页?单栏还是双栏?您是按照模板来写的么?我是图像去雾方向,不知道要不要?
----
不应该是看不上吧,我觉得他认为不符合期刊范围。不过一天就退了也是好事,总比耗你几个月拒稿强
----
8楼2019-05-05 22:37:16
上一篇:浙江农业学报
留言与评论(共有 0 条评论) |